top of page

Let me ask you a question...

  • Jan 2
  • 3 min read

Updated: Mar 25


In all your leadership training - your NPQH, your courses, your professional development, all of it - how much time was spent on this question: "How do I build and maintain a healthy, productive relationship with my governing board?"


If the answer is "not much" you're not alone. Most headteachers I work with tell me exactly the same thing.


And isn't that extraordinary? When you think about it?


Whether you are a headteacher or CEO, this single relationship - the one between you and your board - is arguably the most influential relationship in your school.


Think about it. Your board approves your budget. They shape strategic direction. They hold you accountable. They can support you through a crisis or make that crisis significantly harder. They can give you the space to lead or they can second-guess every decision you make.


The dynamics between you and your board, the boundaries you set - or don't -the expectations that are spoken and unspoken, the conversations that happen and the ones that get avoided, the patterns that develop over time... all of this shapes your entire working life as a headteacher.


And yet, we operate in a system where there is rarely adequate investment in developing this relationship.


We train headteachers and boards on governance structures, on policy, on their legal responsibilities. But we don't train them on how to actually work together. On how to build a relationship that's characterised by trust, clarity, and genuine partnership rather than tension, confusion, and careful management.


I've sat with headteachers who feel stressed, isolated, or deeply frustrated. And when we dig into what's actually driving that, it's often the relationship with their board:


  • Unclear boundaries

  • Misaligned expectations

  • Conversations that never quite happen

  • Patterns that repeat and nobody stops to examine them


One headteacher told me recently: "I sometimes feel I spend more energy managing my board than I do leading my school. And that can't be right."


She's not unusual.


Here's what's particularly painful about this...


Both sides usually want something better.


Headteachers don't want to feel unsupported or second-guessed. They want a board they can genuinely use as thinking partners.


Governors don't want to be kept at arm's length or carefully managed. They want to be trusted, to make a real contribution, to work in genuine partnership with their headteacher.


Both sides want the same thing. But neither side has been given the tools to build it.


So what happens instead?


Patterns develop. The headteacher learns to be careful about what they share. The board senses they're being managed and starts digging for information. The headteacher becomes more defensive. The board becomes more scrutinising.


And round it goes.


Or alternatively: the relationship stays polite, professional, and fundamentally distant. Nobody's in conflict. But nobody's in real partnership either. The headteacher does their thinking alone. The board approves decisions they had no part in shaping. Everyone says "fine" when asked how the relationship is.


And fine isn't good enough.


Because here's what I know:


When the relationship between a headteacher and their board is healthy - when there's clarity, trust, and genuine partnership - everything else becomes easier.


Strategic decisions are made with confidence. Difficult situations are navigated together. The headteacher feels genuinely supported. The board feels genuinely useful.


The school stands on solid ground.


But when that relationship is strained -even if it's not obviously broken, just... not quite right - everything else is harder.


The headteacher carries more than they need to. The board operates from anxiety rather than strategy. Important conversations get avoided. Energy gets drained on managing dynamics rather than leading the school.


And the children pay the price.


It's time the system treated this relationship with the seriousness it deserves.


Not as a nice-to-have. Not as something you just figure out as you go along. But as fundamental to effective school leadership.


This is what I work on. Just this. The dynamics, the boundaries, the expectations, the conversations, the patterns between you and your governing board.


Not general leadership coaching. This specific relationship. Because it's overlooked in every other leadership development space. And that's a problem.


So I'll leave you with this:


How would you honestly describe your relationship with your governing board right now?


Is it genuinely supportive? Or is it "fine" -which often means not great, not terrible, but not what it could be?


Because if you're somewhere in the "fine" category, I want you to know: there's a path to something better.


You deserve clarity. Alignment. Trust. Real support.


And your board probably wants to give you that.


But no one really talks about how.


That's the work. That's where I focus. And it changes everything.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Governor Who Left

She'd been on the board for three years when she handed in her resignation. The letter cited personal commitments. A change in her professional situation. The usual language of an exit that doesn't wa

 
 
 
A thought on defensiveness

We talk about defensiveness in leadership as though it is a problem to be managed. A response to be controlled. Something to notice in yourself and smooth over before anyone else notices it too. But I

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page